Field of Science

Musical Interlude - International Paranoia Edition

I was listening to this track recently, and decided that it rather aptly summed up my current attitude to world politics:

Linnaeus' Legacy # 11 - Giant Head-sized Isopod Edition

A bumper-sized edition of Linnaeus' Legacy has splashed down at The Other 95%, and has certainly aggregated 95% of the links. This month's keywords: extremely risque, wild shores, Zoobank, biglebowski, two personalities, House of Lords, playful and irreverent, Bond, beetle family tree, algebraic geometry, common data network, sex = death, superorganisms, diversity of forms, giant clam, bivalves don't all look the same, hermits, conservation of whale lice, olive-backed forest robin, Honor an Invert, self-recognition, Wolfquest, that will rock, singing, biodiversity and limits. Also, a tribute to echinoderm researcher Cynthia Ahearn.

Hyphae without Nuclei: Filamentous Bacteria


Sporangia of Streptosporangium nondiastaticum. Image from Atlas of Actinomycetes.


Large size can have its advantages. Pound for pound, a large organism is often more energy-efficient than a small one. A larger organism may have an edge in competing for resources. Larger organisms may be less at risk from predation by other organisms. Therefore, it follows that even when life was a single-cell only affair, things would eventually get bigger. However, large size can also have its disadvantages. If we imagine (for the sake of argument) that the original single cells were roughly spherical, then increase in overall volume occurs much faster than overall surface area - exponentially faster, in fact. As the ratio of surface area to volume decreases, the efficiency of movement of nutrients and other other respiratory requirements into the cell and waste products out of the cell also decreases, until eventually a point is reached where it is no longer possible to move stuff in and out of the cell enough to meet the cell's requirements for survival. At this point, the organism essentially has only one of two options if it wishes (speaking metaphorically, of course) to keep growing. One is the option that our far-distant ancestors took - going multicellular, so that instead of being one large, inefficient sphere the organism can be many, more efficient spheres. The other option is arguably simpler - why stick to a sphere? Why not go filamentous? This week's highlight taxon belongs to one group of organisms that did just that - the bacterial family Streptosporangiaceae.

The filamentous option has actually been taken up by more clades of organisms than has true multicellularity. In an evolutionary sense, it's much easier - multicellular organisms require a host of measures to hold cells together and transport materials between them. Filamentous organisms, at the most basic level, simply need to grow along one geometrical axis faster than they grow along the others. Indeed, filamentous organisms rather blur the line between "multicellular" and "unicellular". Many of the larger filamentous organisms such as have cross-membranes dividing sections of hyphae, but they don't necessarily have to. Fungi and xenophyophores are both groups of organisms made up of masses of filaments, and is there any real reason other than comparative tradition for one to be regarded as multicellular and one as unicellular? (Does the concept of a "cell" even really apply when discussing hyphal organisms?) Bacteria are usually imagined as being unicellular, but many members of two bacterial groups, the cyanobacteria (blue-green algae) and the somewhat slime-mould-like Myxococcales, are multicellular for at least part of their life cycles. In contrast, the group of bacteria that made a go of the filamentous life-style was the Actinobacteria, the group to which the Streptosporangiaceae belong. Actinobacteria (or actinomycetes) include a diverse range of bacteria, both filamentous and not so (another subgroup of the Actinobacteria, the Corynebacterineae, has previously been covered here and here). Because of our shaky understanding of bacterial phylogenetics, it's difficult to say anything truly meaningful about the evolution of the filamentous habit in Actinobacteria, but it has most likely been lost and regained a number of times in the group. Some of the Actinobacteria have developed the hyphal habit to the extent that they are superficially ver similar to fungi, and indeed have been classified as such in the past.


Sporangia of Planomonospora alba. Image from Atlas of Actinomycetes.


The Streptosporangiaceae include some of the more mould-like actinobacteria. Like fungi, Streptosporangiaceae form branching, non-fragmenting hyphae. Most (but not all) members produce aerial mycelia, on the ends of which are produced the spores. Rather unusually among bacteria, the various genera can mostly be distinguished by morphological features related to the production of sporangia and arrangement of spores (Tamura et al., 2000), leading to many of them being give such names as Planomonospora or Microtetraspora. Planotetraspora, for instance, bears long, cylindrical sporangia containing four spores in a single row (Tamura & Sakane, 2004), while Acrocarpospora produces spherical or club-shaped sporangia containing coiled spore chains (Tamura et al., 2000). The distinctive appearance of Streptosporangiaceae also means that they are one of the few non-cyanobacterial prokaryote groups with an established fossil record, thanks to the description of Streptosporangiopsis from Cretaceous amber (Waggoner, 1994).

While widespread in soils around the world, the Streptosporangiaceae have often been regarded as rare compared to other groups. As methods of culturing them have improved, however, it has been suggested that Streptosporangiaceae are not so much rare as slow-growing. When soil samples are cultured in the laboratory, they are unable to compete with faster-growing taxa (Lazzarini et al., 2000), and their isolation requires the application of stressors that they can handle better than their competitors, such as heat-drying or chlorinating compounds. Despite the difficulty of culturing them, it has been suggested that doing so would be worthwhile - Streptosporangiaceae have proven a promising target in research into isolating new antibiotic compounds.

REFERENCES

Lazzarini, A., L. Cavaletti, G. Toppo & F. Marinelli. 2000. Rare genera of actinomycetes as potential producers of new antibiotics. Antonie van Leeuwenhoek 78 (3-4): 399-405.

Tamura, T., & S. Sakane. 2004. Planotetraspora silvatica sp. nov. and emended description of the genus Planotetraspora. International Journal of Systematic and Evolutionary Microbiology 54 (6): 2053-2056.

Tamura, T., S. Suzuki & K. Hatano. 2000. Acrocarpospora gen. nov., a new genus of the order Actinomycetales. International Journal of Systematic and Evolutionary Microbiology 50 (3): 1163-1171.

Waggoner, B. M. 1994. Fossil microorganisms from Upper Cretaceous amber of Mississippi. Review of Palaeobotany and Palynology 80 (1-2): 75-84.

Phylogenetic Nomenclature - Oui ou Non?

We may or may not be passing through a revolution in taxonomy. That's the problem with revolutions - it's often unclear whether one is happening or not until it is over, by which point (because humans have an incredible tendency to assume that the status has always been quo) it generally doesn't seem revolutionary any more. The subject in taxonomy that in recent years has caused a great deal of ink to be spilled and keyboards thumped is the question of phylogenetic nomenclature. I'd like to express a few of my thoughts on this subject today. I'm not going to try and actually solve the debate - I'm a pretty determined fence-sitter in this case, and in practice I tend to mix and match systems as circumstances require. Still, there are a number of misconceptions running about that keep rearing their heads, begging to beaten back down in an endless game of philosophical Whack-A-Mole. There are, I think, perfectly valid reasons why the concept of phylogenetic nomenclature is one that should be instituted with caution. It's just that, wierdly, these are not the "reasons" most commonly brought up.

First, some textbook cardboard. Our current taxonomic systems date their academic heritage back to Carl Linnaeus, who in his Systema Naturae adopted the concept of dividing organisms (and minerals) between hierarchically-nested categories, the "ranks" of class, order, genus and species, with the last two ranks together representing the individual name of a given species. As a result, the nomenclatural system most widely used today is generally referred to as the "Linnaean" or "rank-based" system. Through various circumlocutions, this system has given rise to our current codes of nomenclature, which all share two main priciples relevant to this post - taxa are divided between nested hierarchical ranks, and each ranked taxon has a type (genus or species) at a lower rank whose inclusion is a pre-requisite in defining the concept of that taxon. The Zoological Code only covers taxa up to the ranks of family and superfamily and does not regulate higher ranks, while the Botanical and Bacterial Codes cover taxa up to class (Bacterial) or phylum (Botanical) level. Beyond these basic pre-requisites, the Codes are actually quite free and easy. The Codes demand that a "family" must be a subset of an "order", and not the other way around, but there is absolutely no official guideline as to what degree of divergence constitutes an "order" or a "family". For instance, humans have been included by many systematists in a family Hominidae separate from the great apes in the family Pongidae. However, it is now widely accepted that some of the apes are actually more closely related to humans than to other apes - specifically, that chimpanzees and humans form a clade that excludes gorillas, while all three form a clade that excludes orangutans. Some authors have represented this change of concept by including great apes and humans in a single family Hominidae, with a subfamily Ponginae for the orangutan and Homininae for humans and African apes. Others would retain the family Pongidae for the orangutans only, while placing the remainder in the family Hominidae divided between the Gorillinae (gorillas) and Homininae (humans and chimpanzees). Still others might divide the chimpanzees in a separate subfamily from humans. The thing is that the current systems of nomenclature make absolutely no distinction between these various set-ups. All the available options satisfy the basic requirements - subfamily Homininae (if used) is a subset of family Hominidae, and Hominidae always includes the genus Homo. Beyond that, the only thing determining which option an author uses is their own personal judgement on how different a human is from a chimpanzee. Consider, also, the following figure from Baum et al. (1998) (click on it to see a larger figure):



This figure shows phylogenetic relationships within the "core Malvales", a clade of flowering plants previously divided between the families Malvaceae, Bombacaceae, Tiliaceae and Sterculiaceae, but for which all families except Malvaceae had turned out to be para- or polyphyletic. The figure shows four alternative methods of re-classifying the core Malvales in light of improved phylogenetic understanding. The point is that despite the siginificant differences in appearance between the alternative systems (recognising from one to nine families, two to nine subfamilies, etc.), there is actually no difference in the underlying phylogeny. Nevertheless, all four classifications are equally valid because all four meet the requirements of the rank-based system of nomenclature. Because there is no philosophical underpinning to what each "rank" means, the only guideline is a sense of tradition about what has been referred to a certain rank in the past - and because workers on different groups of organisms have different traditions, this is meaningless. As pointed out by David Marjanović in the comments at Tet Zoo, ranks can be (and, all too often, actually are) actively misleading because the temptation to assume that a "genus" of insects is somehow directly comparable to a "genus" of rodents has proven irresistible far too often in the past. Take another look at the Baum et al. figure above. Is "subfamily Malvoideae" in option C a less significant taxon than "family Tiliaceae" in option A?

Problems have also arisen in rank-based nomenclature because of the sheer number of ranks sometimes required. Kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus and species is easy enough to keep track of, but nowhere near enough to deal with the ten million or so species that infest this planet. Take something as boring and well-known as the common house sparrow, Passer domesticus. Passer domesticus belongs to the genus Passer, which is part of the family Passeridae, which belongs to the Passeroidea, part of the Eupasseri, part of the Passerida, part of the Euoscines, part of the Oscines, Eupasseres, Passeriformes, Anomalogonatae, Coronaves, Neoaves, Neognathae, Aves, Ornithurae, Ornithothoraces, Avialae, Eumaniraptora, Metornithes, Maniraptora, Maniraptoriformes, Coelurosauria, Neotetanurae, Tetanurae, Neotheropoda, Theropoda, Saurischia, Dinosauria, Ornithotarsi, Dinosauriformes, Ornithodira, Archosauria, Archosauriformes, Archosauromorpha, Sauria, Neodiapsida, Eosuchia, Diapsida, Eureptilia, Reptilia, Sauropsida, Amniota, Cotylosauria, Batrachosauria, Anthracosauria, Neostegalia, Tetrapoda, Tetrapodomorpha, Sarcopterygii, Osteichthyes, Teleostomi, Gnathostomata, Vertebrata, Craniata, Olfactores, Chordata, Deuterostomia, Eutriploblastica, Bilateria, Eumetazoa, Animalia, Holozoa, Opisthokonta, Unikonta, Eukaryota, Neomura. Try thinking up ranks for every one of that lot! Some pretty horrendous terms such as "supersubphylum" have been perpetrated in such attempts.

It is response to such issues that the concepts of phylogenetic nomenclature and rankless taxonomy arose. In phylogenetic nomenclature, a taxonomic name is defined in relation to an underlying phylogeny (Queiroz & Gaulthier, 1990). For instance, in my first example above, "Hominidae" may have been defined as the largest possible clade that includes humans (Homo) but not orangutans (Pongo). In that case, under the phylogeny given above, chimpanzees and gorillas must belong to Hominidae, while orangutans cannot. Ever. Concordant with the development of phylogenetic nomenclature has been the concept of a rankless taxonomic system. The two are generally assumed to be equivalent by many critics of phylogenetic nomenclature, but in fact they are not. Theoretically, it would be still be possible to erect a system of phylogenetic nomenclature that assigned ranks to the taxa it recognised. It would also be possible to devise a rankless taxonomic system that was not based on phylogeny but on, for instance, overall morphological similarity only. These options have not been considered because, quite simply, they would offer no advantage over the current rank-based system. A ranked phylogenetic system would have the same "too many ranks" problem of the current system, as well as problems all of its own devising if, e.g., conflicting definitions required that one "family" refer to a subset of another "family".

As an aside, I think it is also important to distinguish between the Codes of Nomenclature and the principles underlying their construction. While the rank-based system has its current codes, the (in)famous PhyloCode is in the process of being drafted to regulate phylogenetic nomenclature. The rank-based codes may have the same underlying principles, but they differ in their regulations as a result of different opinions on the most effective means of serving those principles. Similarly, whether or not the PhyloCode is adequate as a regulatory code is a separate issue from whether phylogenetic nomenclature is worthwhile as a concept.

It goes without saying that the concept of phylogenetic nomenclature has had its share of detractors, both on the front of phylogenetic nomenclature in the strict sense, and on the front of rank-free taxonomy. Of the two fronts, it is actually the first that is (in my opinion) the easiest to deal with. One of the main complaints about phylogenetic nomenclature is that it effectively eliminates the possibility of paraphyletic taxa. Take the classic example of Reptilia (reptiles), a paraphyletic "class" that actually includes the ancestors of another "class", Aves (birds). Under phylogenetic nomenclature, Reptilia must either include birds, or be abandoned as a taxon. Supporters of the rank-based systems may point at modern representatives of the two "classes" - lizards, crocodiles, birds - and argue that because crocodiles are more similar to lizards, despite being closer phylogenetically to birds, lizards and crocodiles represent a paraphyletic grade that merits official recognition. However, this ultimately comes down to a judgement call that the similarities between lizards and crocodiles are more "significant" than the similarities between crocodiles and birds. It is also largely an artifact of the extinction of taxa intermediate between the latter two. Would the division be regarded as being as "obvious" if ceratopsians had survived to the present? What about allosaurs? With any paraphyletic taxon, a point is reached where an arbitrary line has to be drawn that exagerrates the differences between taxa on either side of that line. What is so significant about the difference between Archaeopteryx and Microraptor that one should be placed in a separate "class" from the other?

Despite what might be expected, the idea of a rank-free classification is actually more problematic than paraphyly-free classification. This may make no sense at first glance, because the ranked system seems philosophically almost indefensible. The thing is that, ultimately, the appeal of the ranked system doesn't lie in its philosophical defensibility at all. Rather, the rank-based system has such a strong appeal because of its usefulness as an initial didactic and organising tool. Students find it much easier to gain and remember a quick understanding of the hierarchical relationships of taxa if they have a set of pegs to pin them on. Also, people find it helpful to have an "agreed" list of significant taxa. It is often claimed that the rank-based system is somehow more stable than the phylogenetic system, because change in phylogenetic understanding can supposedly lead to sweeping changes in the contents of phylogenetically-defined taxa. The problem is that this stability is nothing more than an illusion. Not only does it feed into the comparability error I referred to earlier, but the "agreed" list is all too often nowhere near as "agreed" as people think it is. Take Aydin Örstan's comment on the seemingly straightforward aim of seeing at least one member of every animal phylum:

But, first, I need to figure out how many animal phyla there are. However, that is not an as easy task as it seems. Wikipedia lists 36, the Animal Diversity Web lists 32 and the University of California Museum of Paleontology gives 25 extant animal phyla.


The phylogenetic system is indeed prone to change with changing phylogenies, but so is the rank-based system. What is more, as shown in the Hominidae and core Malvales examples above, there doesn't even need to be a change in phylogeny, only a change in an individual author's perception of the "significance" of differences.

Overall, I have (initially somewhat reluctantly) come to the conclusion that from a philosophical position, phylogenetic nomenclature knocks down the rank-based system without even breaking a sweat. This does not mean that we should all be rushing headlong to embrace PN - I said at the very beginning of this post that there is cause for caution. The primary handicap of phylogenetic nomenclature is simply that it requires a pretty good understanding of phylogeny (well, duh). For some groups of organisms, such as apes, we have extremely good understandings of their phylogeny. Yes, it is still possible that our views may change with increasing study, but it is extremely unlikely that, say, humans aren't closely related to apes at all but instead convergently evolved from a giant Mediterranean dormouse. For other groups of organisms, our phylogenetic understanding is more minimal. My own stomping ground, harvestmen of the superfamily Phalangioidea, represents a few thousand species of arthropod for which the classification remains almost entirely untested phylogenetically. Phalangioids are divided between a number of families, subfamilies and genera, yes, but all too often the boundaries between taxa frankly couldn't be vaguer if they had been drawn up in the back of a van by Cheech and Chong. Nevertheless, three thousand or so species is far too many to be assimilated in one hit, and the current rank-based system does allow us to break them up into a set of more manageable bits. Attempting to impose a phylogenetic classification onto phalangioids in our current state of knowledge would be a decidedly rash and hasty move, because there is no confidence that the sort of sweeping content changes that the phylogenetic nomenclature critics claim to fear wouldn't happen. A phylogenetic system for some groups of organisms remains more of a target than a current possibility.

REFERENCES

Baum, D. A., W. S. Anderson & R. Nyffeler. 1998. A durian by any other name: taxonomy and nomenclature of the core Malvales. Harvard Papers in Botany 3: 315-330.

Queiroz, K. de, & J. Gauthier. 1990. Phylogeny as a central principle in taxonomy: phylogenetic definitions of taxon names. Systematic Zoology 39 (4): 307-322.

Fleshy Farewells

Three recent arrivals on the carnival rounds:

For things wet and squashy, see Carnival of the Blue at The Saipan Blog.

For things green and hayfevery, see Berry Go Round at Not Exactly Rocket Science.

For things hard and sedimentary, see The Boneyard at When Pigs Fly Returns.

And a reminder that Linnaeus' Legacy posts need to be in by the day after tomorrow!

When Ferns Don't Look Like Ferns

I suspect that I would hardly need to explain to anyone what a fern looks like - their cool, green, graceful appearance makes them a favourite of holders of foliage fetishes everywhere. What you possibly may not be aware with is that the classic fern is actually only part of the story. Odds are that the parent of the fern you next see growing in a pot or in a damp grove looked nothing like that fern, and if you took the spores of that fern and grew them, you may not recognise the product. Welcome to the world of alternating generations.



Alternation of generations is actually something that all land plants indulge in. A diploid sporophyte asexually produces haploid spores that grow into haploid gametophytes whose haploid gametes fuse to form the zygotes that grows into new sporophytes, as shown in the diagram above by Jeffrey Finkelstein. In seed plants, the gametophyte has been severely reduced and does not grow outside its parent - the female gametophyte remains contained within the parent flower or cone as the ovule, while the male gametophyte is only a few cells in size and forms the pollen grain. In ferns, the gametophyte grows as a separate (albeit really small - perhaps only about a centimetre across) individual with an undifferentiated thallus. Each gametophyte produces both male and female gametes at different places on the thallus, and male gametes require a layer of moisture across the surface to swim across to the female gametes and fertilise them. Cross-fertilisation occurs when multiple gametophytes grow in close proximity and joined by a common covering of moisture. The sporophyte then grows directly out of the parent gametophyte.

In the majority of fern species, the gametophyte is a small heart-shaped structure like in the diagram above. The meristem, the growing part of the plant, is restricted to the recessed point of the heart. In three fern families, though, the gametophyte is ribbon-like or filamentous with multiple marginal meristems and grows indeterminately. While gametophytes of other fern families tend to be short-lived affairs, the gametophytes of Hymenophyllaceae, Vittariaceae and Grammitidaceae can be much longer-lived. Dassler and Farrar (1997) recorded an individual gametophyte of the Hymenophyllaceae species Callistopteris baueriana still growing seven years after germination. What is more, some inderminately-growing gametophytes are able to reproduce asexually as well as sexually through the production of gemmae, side-buds that can detach and grow into new individuals (anyone who has owned a hen-and-chickens fern or a mother-of-millions plants may have seen gemmae growing along the edge of their leaves). For a very few species, this capacity for sexual reproduction has allowed them to bypass the sporophyte phase of the life-cycle entirely.


The gametophyte-only fern species Vittaria appalachiana. Photo by Bob Klips.


Currently, independent gametophytes (i.e. those that are able to establish populations without forming sporophytes) are known from a single species of Grammitidaceae, two Vittariaceae and nine Hymenophyllaceae (Lindsay, 2003). Most of these species also produce sporophytes over part of the distribution, but the gametophytes are able to survive in areas that are seemingly not conducive to sporophyte production. Vittaria graminifolia, for instance, is known in Louisiana only as gametophytes, with the nearest sporophytes of the species over a thousand kilometres away in Mexico (Lindsay, 2003). As yet, only three species are known that seemingly never produce sporophytes - Vittaria appalachiana, Hymenophyllum tayloriae and Trichomanes intricatum (Raine et al., 1991; Farrar, 1992). Nevertheless, there are good reasons to suspect that the diversity of unrecognised independent gametophytes out there might be much higher. Fern gametophytes have been studied much less than sporophytes - not only are they small and difficult to find, but they have generally been regarded as decidedly low on taxonomically useful characters. Vittaria appalachiana, the first-known gametophyte-only species, was actually discovered sixty years before it was confirmed to be identifiably distinct from sporophyte-producing species of Vittaria. It does not escape notice that all three known gametophyte-only species come from the eastern United States, even though the families involved are found in tropical and subtropical habitats throughout the world. Things become particularly suspicious when you realise that a single person, Donald Farrar of Iowa State University, has been privy to the description of all three. More than likely, the apparent absence of gametophyte-only species from other parts of the world does not suggest that there is something unusual about the eastern United States, but simply that no-one has really looked anywhere else.

Like the relationship between asexually- and sexually-reproducing fungi, the taxonomic and ecological implications of the independent gametophyte may be significant. Rumsey et al. (1999) demonstrated that the Killarney fern (Trichomanes speciosum), previously regarded as extremely rare in the British Isles based on the distribution of the sporophyte, was actually fairly widespread and common as the gametophyte. The wide distribution of the eastern North American Trichomanes intricatum, including areas previously subject to glaciation and despite the apparent low dispersal potential of gametophytes reproducing by gemmae only, led Farrar (1992) to suggest that the "extinction" of the sporophyte form may have happened only recently. Has this species really forever lost the ability to produce sporophytes, or might a change of climate lead to the unfurling of a long-forgotten frond deep within the forests of New England?

REFERENCES

Dassler, C. L., & D. R. Farrar. 1997. Significance of form in fern gametophytes: Clonal, gemmiferous gametophytes of Callistopteris baueriana (Hymenophyllaceae). International Journal of Plant Sciences 158 (5): 622-639.

Farrar, D. R. 1992. Trichomanes intricatum: the independent Trichomanes gametophyte in the eastern United States. American Fern Journal 82 (2): 68-74.

Lindsay, S. 2003. Considerations for a revision of the fern family Vittariaceae for Flora Malesiana. Telopea 10 (1): 99-112.

Raine, C. A., D. R. Farrar & E. Sheffield. 1991. A new Hymenophyllum species in the Appalachians represented by independent gametophyte colonies. American Fern Journal 81 (4): 109-118.

Rumsey, F. J., J. C. Vogel, S. J. Russell, J. A. Barrett & M. Gibby. 1999. Population structure and conservation biology of the endangered fern Trichomanes speciosum Willd. (Hymenophyllaceae) at its northern distributional limit. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 66 (3): 333-344.

Coral - It's Not Just an Animal Thing


The encrusting coralline alga Hydrolithon onkodes. Photo by J. Orempüller.


Coral reefs form the world's most renowned tropical marine habitat, and are some of the most inspiring structures on the planet's surface. An incredible wealth of biodiversity hides among the reef structure, and reefs are a justly celebrated subject of many popular books. Most of such books will (hopefully) dedicate a reasonable amount of space to the primary constructors of the reef, the corals, describing how these colonial anemone-related cnidarians lay down skeletons of carbonate that, as the layer of coral grows upwards, accumulate to form the reef structure. For today's Taxon of the Week post, I'm going to showcase another significant group of organisms in the formation of coral reefs that tends not to get quite so much press - the coralline red algae of the order Corallinales.

The coralline algae are one of the most distinct groups of the red algae. They receive their name because, like coral, they lay down skeletons of calcium carbonate that both support the organism and dissuade potential grazers. Coralline algae are a very significant component of coral reefs - in at least some areas, coralline algae actually make up a higher percentage of the surface cover of the coral reef than the coral itself. Overgrowth by coralline algae can bind the reef structure, making it more resilient to erosion and wave action. In areas of coral reef restoration, coral larvae settle preferentially on substrate that is already overgrown by coralline algae (Precht, 2006). Coralline algae are also able to withstand lower temperatures and higher-energy environments than corals, meaning that algae-dominated reefs also have a much wider distribution than true coral reefs. Coralline algae also include some of the deepest-living photosynthetic organisms in the world, with some species growing at depths of 300 m, in light levels only 0.0005% of surface level that would be imperceptible to humans.


The articulate coralline alga Corallina officinalis. Photo from habitas.org.uk.


Morphologically, coralline algae are often divided into two groups, geniculate or articulate and non-geniculate or crustose coralline algae. Geniculate coralline algae grow in branching upright thalli formed of a series of segments divided by joints called genicula. Crustose coralline algae generally do just what the label says they do - they usually grow as flat crusts, though sometimes they may grow upright branches which never grow as high as geniculate algae and are never segmented. Some crustose coralline algae actually grow unattached to the substrate and form often rounded, rock-like structures called rhodoliths that in some places litter the sea floor in large rhodolith beds. Rhodoliths grow extremely slowly - Frantz et al. (2000) calculated a growth rate of approximately 0.6 mm per year using carbon-14 mass spectrometry of rhodolith sections, suggesting that the largest rhodoliths with diameters of over ten centimetres could be 100 years old or more. Such slow growth is characteristic of coralline algae as a whole - experimental observations on reef sections where grazers were excluded showed that in their absence the coralline algae quickly became overgrown by fouling macroalgae.

Unfortunately, and despite their ecological significance, systematic studies of coralline algae are relatively few and far between, largely because of the difficulties of working with them taxonomically. Many morphologically informative characters require examination under a compound microscope, a particularly challenging prospect for crustose forms which are, after all, essentially a thin layer of living tissue over a core of solid rock. Despite its superficial convenience, smaller scale morphological features and molecular phylogeny indicate that the division between geniculate and crustose forms is not phylogenetically informative (Harvey et al., 2003). Instead, Harvey et al. (2003) divided the living Corallinales into three families, the Sporolithaceae, Corallinaceae and Hapalidiaceae, based on molecular data as well as the arrangement and morphology of the sporangia. Corallinales have the stupidly complicated life-cycles of the average floridean red alga (though not so stupidly complicated as some), but the important detail is that generations alternate between morphologically identical haploid and diploid generations (Hoek et al., 1995). Corallinales have also not indulged in parasitism to the extent of other red algal groups, though two members of Hapalidiaceae, Choreonema thuretii and Austrolithon intumescens, are endophytic parasites of the Corallinaceae species Jania tenella (Broadwater et al., 2002).


Rhodolith bed off the coast of Alaska. Photo by Brenda Konar.


Not surprisingly, coralline algae have a pretty detailed fossil record compared to other algal groups, but, unfortunately, I suspect that a certain degree of scepticism is called for here. I've alluded before to the difficulty of interpreting fossil "algae" in relation to modern taxa - because the type of fine-scale microscopic features used in establishing the relationships of living algal taxa are usually unknown for fossil taxa, the risk that supposed overall resemblances may be the results of convergence rather than true relationship runs pretty high. Fairly unequivocal crown-group coralline algae of all three living families date back to the Cretaceous (Aguirre et al., 2000), but taxa dating right back to near the beginning of the Palaeozoic have also been identified as Corallinales or close relatives. Indeed the Silurian Gracticulaceae have been regarded as being only doubtfully distinct from the living Sporolithaceae (Harvey et al., 2003) - though accepting them as such would demand one heck of a ghost lineage between the Silurian and the Cretaceous. The Palaeozoic "Solenoporaceae" also turn up repeatedly in connection with discussions of Corallinales, but the integrity of this group has been regarded as debatable in recent years. Most significantly, the actual type species of the Solenoporaceae, the Ordovician Solenopora spongioides, was recently demonstrated by Riding (2004) to be not an alga at all, but actually a sponge!

REFERENCES

Aguirre, J., R. Riding & J. C. Braga. 2000. Diversity of coralline red algae: origination and extinction patterns from the early Cretaceous to the Pleistocene. Paleobiology 26 (4): 651-667.

Broadwater, S. T., A. S. Harvey, E. A. Lapointe & W. J. Woelkerling. 2002. Conceptacle structure of the parasitic coralline red alga Choreonema thuretii (Corallinales) and its taxonomic implications. Journal of Phycology 38 (6): 1157-1168.

Frantz, B. R., M. Kashgarian, K. H. Coale & M. S. Foster. 2000. Growth rate and potential climate record from a rhodolith using 14C accelerator mass spectrometry. Limnol. Oceanogr. 45 (8): 1773-1777.

Harvey, A. S., S. T. Broadwater, W. J. Woelkerling & P. J. Mitrovski. 2003. Choreonema (Corallinales): 18S rDNA phylogeny and resurrection of the Hapalidiaceae for the subfamilies Choreonematoideae, Austrolithoideae, and Melobesioideae. Journal of Phycology 39 (5): 988-998.

Hoek, C., D. G. Mann & H. M. Jahns. 1995. Algae: An Introduction to Phycology. Cambridge University Press.

Precht, W. F. 2006. Coral Reef Restoration Handbook. CRC Press.

Riding, R. 2004.
Solenopora is a chaetetid sponge, not an alga. Palaeontology 47 (1): 117-122.