Field of Science

"Anatomy of Mollusca": A Case of Plagiarism

Whilst researching material for an upcoming post, I came across this book on Google Books, published in 2010 by the International Scientific Publishing Agency, New Delhi:
Anatomy of Mollusca, by Rita Rawat


Looking at the section previewed through Google Books, I couldn't help feeling that it seemed a little... familiar. Take a look at this screenshot from Google Books:

Now take a look at this screenshot, taking from a page written by my erstwhile associates at Palaeos.com, last modified in 2006:

I can only go by what was available in the Google Books preview, of course, without direct access to the actual book, but I can confirm that most if not all of the material in pages 15 to 72 at least of the "Anatomy of Mollusca" appears to have been copied directly from Palaeos.com (unfortunately, a large part of Palaeos.com is currently offline as the site gets revamped). A quick Google search failed to uncover anything indicating whether the International Scientific Publishing Agency has a reputation for publishing lifted material, so I can't say if this is part of a broader issue.

Amazon currently has the "Anatomy of Mollusca" on sale for just over $75. Not that expensive by the standards of technical publications, but a fair chunk of change by the standards of books in general. Certainly a lot more than the cost of reading the same stuff on Palaeos.com, which carries no extra cost beyond that of the ISP charges.

Dung Beetles

Flat-headed dung beetles Pachylomerus femoralis with a ball of the good stuff, photographed by Guido Coza.


The dung beetles of the Scarabaeini include 146 species found in Africa and Asia, classified by Forgie et al. (2006) into three genera: Pachysoma, Pachylomerus and Scarabaeus, with the last including the vast majority of species. The Scarabaeus species are perhaps the most famous of all dung beetles, renowned since ancient history when Egyptians saw a dung beetle rolling a ball of dung along the ground as a metaphor for the movement of the sun through the heavens*. Dung beetles collect their turd balls to use as food for themselves or for their larvae. Ball-rolling is not unique to the Scarabaeini as a method of transporting dung, however (it is also done by members of other dung beetle tribes), nor do all Scarabaeini species engage in ball-rolling.

*It probably does not say much for the standard of ancient Egyptian public sanitation that they were apparently so willing to believe that the ultimate source of all life on the planet was a giant mass of burning poop.

Flightless orange dung beetle Pachysoma denticolle, photographed by Alex Dreyer.


The flightless dung beetles of the genus Pachysoma, for instance, transport their food by dragging it along between their hind legs. Pachysoma species are also less choosy than other Scarabaeini, feeding not just on dung but all manner of organic detritus. They have specialisations allowing them to feed on drier food particles than other Scarabaeini, suitable for their arid habitats in southern Africa. In contrast, species of the subgenus Sceliages within Scarabaeus are the epicures of the scarabaein world: they feed entirely on dead millipedes, which they push along in front of themselves bulldozer-style (Forgie et al. 2005). Relatively few species of Scarabaeini feed by burrowing directly alongside piles of dung where they lay, but this may be done by Pachylomerus and Scarabaeus galenus (both of which may also transport food).

Individual of Sceliages transporting a millipede, photographed by Shaun Forgie.


Most Scarabaeini are active during the day, but a small number such as Scarabaeus satyrus are nocturnal in habit. In the phylogenetic analyses conducted by Forgie et al. (2005), these nocturnal species usually formed a single clade. Had the ancient Egyptians observed the nocturnal dung beetles as well, they could have presented us with a sky full of poo at all hours.

REFERENCES

Forgie, S. A., U. Kryger, P. Bloomer & C. H. Scholtz. 2006. Evolutionary relationships among the Scarabaeini (Coleoptera: Scarabaeidae) based on combined molecular and morphological data. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 40: 662-678.

Forgie, S. A., T. K. Philips & C. H. Scholtz. 2005. Evolution of the Scarabaeini (Scarabaeidae: Scarabaeinae). Systematic Entomology 30: 60-96.

Snap! goes the Termite

The snapping termite Cavitermes tuberosus, from Wiki Termes.


For the subject of today's post, I drew the termite subfamily Termitinae. Termites are extraordinary animals: socially complex, ecologically vital, dietically remarkable. Personally, I'm rather found of these communal cockroaches.

Termites of the family Termitidae (commonly referred to as the 'higher termites') differ from other, 'lower' termites in the nature of their gut biota (without which they would not be able to digest their cellulose diets): instead of having flagellated protozoa in their gut, termitids carry symbiotic bacteria. This difference in symbionts is reflected by a difference in diet. Higher termites feed on more decayed wood or plant matter than lower termites; some higher termites feed directly on organic-rich soil that contains little or no plant material (Inward et al. 2007). Subfamilies within the Termitidae are also distinguished on the basis of their gut anatomy: members of the Termitinae have what is called a 'mixed segment' on the outer edge of their intestine (Lo & Eggleton 2011). In the mixed segment, instead of the division between the mesenteron (the middle section of the intestine) and the proctodaeum (the posterior section) being simple and straight across, the mesenteron wall extends backwards along one side of the gut only; it has been suggested that the mixed segment functions to pump alkaline fluids into the gut, maintaining appropriate pH and fluid levels for the symbiotic bacteria in the hindgut (Bignell et al. 1983).

Workers of Amitermes dentatus repairing a damaged nest, from here.


The Termitinae have also been distinguished on the basis of the morphology of their soldiers, with most genera having soldiers with elongate mandibles that have relatively few large teeth. These are used to bite and slash at threats to the colony. However, phylogenetic analyses have contradicted this distinction (Inward et al. 2007). The Termitinae are paraphyletic with regard to the Nasutitermitinae, who have developed a very different method of defense: the mandibles are reduced, and instead the front of the head is drawn out into an elongate 'nose'. At the end of the 'nose' is a glandular opening from which the soldiers squirt a sticky glue at their opponents. Also nested within the Termitinae are the Syntermitinae whose soldiers combine both methods of defense: they retain sickle-shaped mandibles that are used to pierce the cuticle of attackers while the protruded glandular opening is used to apply toxic secretions. Chemical defenses are also not unknown among more standard termitines: soldiers of Globitermes sulphureus were dubbed 'walking bombs' by E. O. Wilson due to their explosive (and often self-destructive) discharge of toxic chemicals from hypertrophied labial gland reservoirs in the abdomen. It should also be noted that a small number of termitines do not produce soldiers at all: they may live in association with other soldier-producing termites, like the Australian Invasitermes, or they may feed on low-nutrient soils (presumably making the maintenance of a soldier caste too nutritionally expensive), like the Indomalayan genera Protohamitermes and Orientotermes.

The mushroom-like mound of Cubitermes, a major soil-feeding genus in Africa, photographed by Marco Schmidt.


Another mode of defense that is found only among the termitines (though phylogenetic analysis indicates that it has evolved multiple times) is the production of soldiers with elongate snapping mandibles. In these termites, soldiers store kinetic energy through muscular deformation of the mandibles, allowing them to be suddenly closed with great force (Prestwich 1984). So great is the force involved, in fact, that it seems to be not uncommon for the jaws to become completely crossed over as has happened to the individual at the top of this post. Snapping termites generally live in subterranean colonies, and even after the soldier has been 'spent' on the discharge of its mandibles, its body acts as a physical barrier in the confined tunnel. In some snapping termites, the mandibles are strongly asymmetrical, so the force of the closure is channelled through the left mandible only with doubled force. Asymmetrical snappers of the genus Neocapritermes, in fact, are able to knock out fairly large ants with a single blow. The video below shows a soldier of Planicapritermes attacking an ant: Or you can see Neocapritermes in action in this video. Keep a close eye on the screen around the 20-second mark...

REFERENCES

Bignell, D. E., H. Oskarsson, J. M. Anderson & P. Ineson. 1983. Structure, microbial associations and function of the so-called "mixed segment" of the gut in two soil-feeding termites, Procubitermes aburiensis and Cubitermes severus (Termitidae, Termitinae). Journal of Zoology 201: 445-480.

Inward, D. J. G., A. P. Vogler & P. Eggleton. 2007. A comprehensive phylogenetic analysis of termites (Isoptera) illuminates key aspects of their evolutionary biology. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 44: 953-967.

Lo, N., & P. Eggleton. 2011. Termite phylogenetics and co-cladogenesis with symbionts. In: Bignell, D. E., et al. (eds) Biology of Termites: a modern synthesis pp. 27-50. Springer.

Prestwich, G. D. 1984. Defense mechanisms of termites. Annual Review of Entomology 29: 201-232.

Nosybelba: A Uniquely Madagascan Mite

Dorsal and ventral views of the main body of Nosybelba oppiana, from Mahunka (1994).


Why yes, it's another random oribatid! Nosybelba oppiana was described from Madagascar by Sándor Mahunka in 1994; Mahunka regarded it as distinct enough from other oribatids that he placed it in its own monospecific family. To date, the original description appears to be the sum total of our knowledge of Nosybelba oppiana. Subías et al. (2012) transferred it to a separate subfamily within the larger family Oppiidae, and transferred a second Madagascan species 'Oppia spinipes' Balogh 1964 to Nosybelba, but this was in the context of a species checklist only without supporting discussion (also, the name Oppia spinipes was used for an oribatid species by Banks in 1906, so whatever the status of Balogh's species it needs a new name).

Leg I of Nosybelba oppiana, from Mahunka (1994). Femur and genu of the right, tibia and tarsus on the left.


So what can we tell about Nosybelba from its description? One of the first things that attracts attention is that it has rather weird legs. The tarsi (the terminal segments) of the legs are really short, shorter on all legs than the adjoining tibia. On the first pair of legs, the tarsus is also compressed longitudinally, and a dorsal process on the tibia (that bears a large sensory seta) overhangs the tarsus. To my admittedly uneducated eyes, the overall structure does not give an impression of mobility. I'm guessing that Nosybelba is not the most agile of oribatids. At the end of each leg is a single large claw; as mentioned in a previous post, the number of claws on an oribatid's legs tends to correlate with habitat, with single claws suggesting a terrestrial lifestyle.

Lateral view of front end of Nosybelba oppiana (minus legs), from Mahunka (1994).


Another noteworthy feature of Nosybelba can be found in its mouthparts. The mentum, the 'under-head' shelf that underlies the chelicerae, does not have a basal articulation, so the chelicerae are limited in their range of movement. The chelicerae themselves do not have any teeth, so Nosybelba is not feeding on anything that requires a great deal of processing before swallowing. In another oribatid family, the Suctobelbidae, similar chelicerae are related to a diet of plant matter that is in an advanced state of decay; Nosybelba is presumably also a connoiseur of the rotten and the liquefied.

REFERENCES

Banks, N. 1906. New Oribatidae from the United States. Proceedings of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia 58 (3): 490-500.

Mahunka, S. 1994. Oribatids from Madagascar II. (Acari: Oribatida). Revue Suisse de Zoologie 101 (1): 47-88.

Subías, L S., U. Ya. Shtanchaeva & A. Arillo. 2012. Listado de los ácaros oribátidos (Acariformes, Oribatida) de las diferentes regiones biogeográficas del mundo. Monografías electrónicas S.E.A. 4.

Acervulinids: Reef Forams

Regular readers of this site will know that, contrary to common belief, not all representatives of the vaguely defined category of organisms known as 'protozoa' are too small to be seen with the naked eye. Some are very visible indeed, and many of the more visible forms can be found among the shell-constructing amoeboids known as Foraminifera. One group of giant forams, the xenophyophores, has become fairly famous in internet circles as one of the contenders for the title of 'largest single cell', though, as noted in the post linked to, the question is kind of a pointless one with regard to forams. Besides, as described later in this post, xenophyophores may not have even have always been the largest forams.

Encrusting nodules of Acervulina inhaerens from Rhodes, from M. Hesemann.


The Acervulinidae are a family of reef-inhabiting forams belonging among the rotaliids. Juvenile chambers of newly growing acervulinids are arranged in a flat spiral, but chambers of mature specimens may be arranged in one to several layers. The chambers do not have regular apertures, and instead their walls are only pierced by coarse pores (Perrin 1994). Genera and species of acervulinids are distinguished by the presence, arrangement and shapes of layers and chambers, but defining distinctions appropriately is challenging. Acervulinids do not have a determinate 'adult morphology'; instead, the final adult appearance can be affected by factors such as substrate relief and water movement. Properly identifying acervulinids therefore requires identification of features independent of these external factors.

Living crust of Gypsina plana, photographed by Hal Ray Tichenor.

Acervulinids can be abundant on tropical coral reefs, and may play a not insiginificant role in reef formation as binding organisms. They tend to be particularly prominent in deeper parts of the reef, as they can tolerate lower light levels than other organisms such as coralline algae; in shallower parts of the reef, they are found in more cryptic locations among the coral. Acervulinids may be free-living, or they may be directly attached to their substrate. Like the star-shaped calcarinids, their primary food source is benthic diatoms (that they may or may not live with symbiotically), and the abrupt disappearance of the modern Acervulina inhaerens below depths of 130 m probably corresponds to the lower limit of that food source (Bosellini & Papazzoni 2003).

Fossilised nodules from a Solenomeris reef, photographed by Stefano Dominici. Note that Stefano identifies these as Acervulina; due to the complications in distinguishing acervulinid taxa, it remains contentious whether Solenomeris and Acervulina can be reliably separated.


Attached acervulinids may form either nodules or spreading crusts, depending on species and/or growth conditions (Perrin 1994). Such nodules or crusts may have diameters in the millimetre range, but some living species may be within the decimetre range. The most dramatic expression of acervulinid potential, however, was known from the Tethyan region during the Eocene period (the Tethys, for those unfamiliar with it, was the sea that connected the Atlantic and Indian Oceans north of Africa, before the northward movement of that continent closed off the Mediterranean at the eastern end). Here was found Solenomeris ogormani, initially interpreted as a red alga but since reidentified as an acervulinid. Solenomeris was primarily an encrusting form, but large growths would also produce tightly packed branches one or two centimetres in diameter. Over time, Solenomeris formed massive metre-sized domes, and these domes together would form entire reefs stretching over multiple kilometres: reefs formed not of coral, or of algae, but purely of forams!

REFERENCES

Bosellini, F. R., & C. A. Papazzoni. 2003. Palaeoecological significance of coral−encrusting foraminiferan associations: a case−study from the Upper Eocene of northern Italy. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 48 (2): 279-292.

Perrin, C. 1994. Morphology of encrusting and free living acervulinid Foraminifera: Acervulina, Gypsina and Solenomeris. Palaeontology 37 (2): 425-458.

The Range of Lotus

For today's post, I'll be focusing on the lotus. And having said that, how many of you instantly thought of something like this:


To which I can only say: you should be ashamed of yourself. That is not a lotus, that is some wierd aquatic poppy-type thing called Nelumbo nucifera. This is a lotus:

Bird's-foot trefoil Lotus corniculatus, from Lyndon's Garden.


To clarify, Lotus is a genus of over a hundred species of herbaceous legumes native mostly to Eurasia and northern Africa, with smaller numbers of species in sub-Saharan Africa and Australia (Kirkbride 1999). About forty or so species have also been assigned to this genus from the Americas (particularly western North America), but all recent analyses have agreed that the New World species are not immediately related to the Old World species (Allan & Porter 2000; Arambarri et al. 2005) and they have been reclassified as genera Hosackia, Acmispon, Ottleya and Syrmatium—we shall not speak of them again. How the name 'lotus' came to be simultaneously applied to two such different plants as pictured above, I couldn't say, but the practice goes back a long time: the elder Pliny was referring to both sweet clover and a water lily as lotus in the first century AD (Kirkbride 1999). He also used the name 'lotus' for jujubes and (possibly) pomegranates, so he evidently had a certain affection for the word.

Greater lotus Lotus uliginosus, photographed by Forest & Kim Starr.


Lotus species are commonly known as trefoils, in reference to the leaves being divided into three leaflets. As it happens, most Lotus species actually have leaves with five leaflets, but two of those are separated from the others by an extended midrib. Pea-shaped flowers are borne in small terminal clusters; these are most commonly yellow, though some species produce red flowers. A few species have gone by the vernacular name of 'bacon and eggs' in reference to their producing flowers which are a combination of the two colours. Seeds are produced in long straight pods, and the appearance of the clustered pods is responsible for another vernacular name, bird's-foot trefoil. In one group of species, commonly separated as a genus Tetragonolobus but phylogenetically nested among other Lotus (Allan & Porter 2000), the pods bear four longitudinal wings. Even excluding the New World species, the exact number of species recognised in Lotus varies between authors, primarily due to disagreement over the appropriate treatment of segregates of the more widespread and variable taxa.

Young pod and flower of asparagus pea Lotus tetragonolobus, from here.

A number of Lotus species, particularly L. corniculatus and the greater lotus L. uliginosus*, are used as pasture legumes and have become established around the world as a result. Though arguably less productive than alternative legumes such as clover, they are often able to tolerate more marginal habitats (particularly waterlogged ground). Some species do contain secondary metabolites that can produce cyanide, but concentrations are not usually high enough to be a concern. The asparagus pea Lotus tetragonolobus (also known as Tetragonolobus purpureus) is grown for more direct human consumption, with the pods being eaten before they reach maturity. The name 'asparagus pea' is supposed to refer to their flavour, but this website expressed the opinion that: "If you have an excessively moist mouth, and are looking for something to suck all the moisture out and leave you all pasty, then asparagus peas are the vegetable for you."

*There seems to be some disagreement out there about whether Lotus uliginosus should be recognised as distinct from L. pedunculatus. Kirkbride (1999) uses L. uliginosus as a distinct taxon.

REFERENCES

Allan, G. J., & J. M. Porter. 2000. Tribal delimitation and phylogenetic relationships of Loteae and Coronilleae (Faboideae: Fabaceae) with special reference to Lotus: evidence from nuclear ribosomal ITS sequences. American Journal of Botany 87 (12): 1871-1881.

Arambarri, A. M., S. A. Stenglein, M. N. Colares & M. C. Novoa. 2005. Taxonomy of the New World species of Lotus (Leguminosae: Loteae). Australian Journal of Botany 53: 797-812.

Kirkbride, J. H., Jr. 1999. Lotus systematics and distribution. In: Trefoil: The Science and Technology of Lotus, pp. 1-20. Crop Science Society of America and American Society of Agronomy.

The Parulidae: Not-warblers, Not-ovenbirds and Not-redstarts

Black-crested warbler Myiothlypis nigrocristata, photographed by Mikko Pyhälä.


There is no denying the current status of English as the de facto lingua franca of the world*. And yet, I feel that a complaint must be laid at the feet of the Brits: they're a bit unimaginative when it comes to animal names. Many a British explorer, upon being presented with some hitherto unfamiliar product of the natural world, proceeded to label it with the name of whatever inhabitant of his native Europe he felt bore some vague resemblance. And hence, even today, there are significant groups of animals such as the Parulidae that are almost without a vernacular name to genuinely call their own.

*The potential irony of this sentence is not lost on me.

The Parulidae are a family of birds found throughout the Americas, though in the northern United States and Canada they are represented by migratory species that retreat further south in the cold months. Many of the migratory species have males with brightly coloured breeding plumage and are consequently idolised by North American bird watchers; non-migratory species, on the other hand, tend to have similarly subdued males and females (Update: see comments below). Members of the Parulidae are generally referred to as 'warblers' or 'wood warblers', despite not being at all closely related to the European warblers. Instead, parulids are members of the 'nine-primaried oscines', the passerine clade that also includes such birds as finches, buntings, sparrows, cardinals and tanagers. Within the nine-primaried oscines, parulids are closely related to the Icteridae, another American clade containing its fair share of representatives doomed to masquerade under stolen names (Barker et al. 2013).

Ovenbird Seiurus aurocapilla on its nest, photographed by M. C. Donald.


Though the nine-primaried oscines as a whole are fairly stable in their membership, recent years have seen a fair bit of shuffling back and forth between the clade's constituent families. As a result of this shuffling, the name 'Parulidae' has come to be associated with a core clade that excludes a number of more uncertainly placed taxa previously included in the family, such as the Central American wrenthrush Zeledonia coronata. A recent comprehensive study of the molecular phylogeny of the core parulids by Lovette et al. (2010) also resulted in a proposed shifting of many generic boundaries within the clade. According to Lovette et al., the basalmost member of the Parulidae is the ovenbird Seiurus aurocapilla, a migratory but monomorphic, relatively large parulid of North and Central America. Just to confuse matters, the name 'ovenbird' has also been used for an unrelated group of South American birds of the genus Furnarius. To be charitable, this is not a case of inappropriate name-saking, but refers to the construction by both groups of domed nests resembling an old earthernware oven. The next member of the parulids to split off was the worm-eating warbler Helmitheros vermivorus, a relatively long-billed species that migrates between the eastern United States and Central America.

Swainson's warbler Limnothlypis swainsonii, photographed by Greg Lavaty.


Next comes a clade of eight species classified in the genera Parkesia, Vermivora, Mniotilta, Limnothlypis and Protonotaria. The black-and-white warbler Mniotilta varia is noted for its distinctive feeding behaviour: it crawls along branches like a nuthatch or creeper, gleaning insects from the bark. The prothonotary warbler Protonotaria citrea is a bright yellow species that Kurt Vonnegut devoted some time to in Jailbird: "The song of a prothonotary warbler is notoriously monotonous, as I am the first to admit...Still—they are capable of expressing heartbreak—within strict limits, of course" (I personally feel the same about skylarks). The waterthrushes of the genus Parkesia are larger, terrestrially-feeding species.

Chestnut-sided warbler Setophaga pensylvanica, photographed by Cephas.

Other North American species are placed by Lovette et al. in the larger genera Geothlypis, Oreothlypis and Setophaga. The last genus contains the species previously included in Dendroica, but the recognition that the American redstart Setophaga ruticilla (again, no relation to the European redstart) is nested within Dendroica leads to the use of the older name. These genera include some of the most colorful parulids. The remaining genera Myiothlypis, Basileuterus, Cardellina and Myioborus form a mostly Neotropical clade. Myioborus species are also known as redstarts, presumably by comparison with the European birds as not one of them actually possesses a red tail. The name 'whitestart' has supposedly been proposed instead, but the only time that name appears to see use is when it is referred to by someone explaining why they are not using it...

REFERENCES

Barker, K. F., K. J. Burns, J. Klicka, S. M. Lanyon & I. J. Lovette. 2013. Going to extremes: contrasting rates of diversification in a recent radiation of New World passerine birds. Systematic Biology 62 (2): 298-320.

Lovette, I. J., J. L. Pérez-Emán, J. P. Sullivan, R. C. Banks, I. Fiorentino, S. Córdoba-Córdoba, M. Echeverry-Galvis, F. K. Barker, K. J. Burns, J. Klicka, S. M. Lanyon & E. Bermingham. 2010. A comprehensive multilocus phylogeny for the wood-warblers and a revised classification of the Parulidae (Aves). Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 57: 753-770.