If there are any of you who remember the last time I presented a quiz - don't worry, this one will probably be easier. But first, a little background (which may be familiar to some of you):
In 1887, Othniel Charles Marsh described a pair of large fossil horns as Bison alticornis, placing them in the same genus as the modern bison. As it turned out, the horns were not from a bison, they were from a dinosaur, either Triceratops or a close relative (the 'Bison' alticornis remains are not extensive enough to be sure). 'Bison' alticornis is just one of many cases of species originally assigned to genera to which they are no longer regarded as closely related. In some cases, such as the example I've just given, the original author did not have the material available that would have allowed a more accurate placement (ceratopsid fossils combining both dinosaurian characteristics and horns would not be described until a year later, by Marsh himself; at the time he described the alticornis horns, the possibility that they might have come from some sort of gigantic lizard probably never entered the equation). Sometimes, the concept associated with the genus name was simply far broader than its present circumscription (Linnaeus' original concept of Vespertilio, for instance, covered all bats). And sometimes, the characters regarded as defining a genus were different from the characters used today (Linnaeus' Falco was defined as carnivorous birds with a feathered head, hooked beak and without a covering of bristles at the base of the beak; it therefore included members of modern Accipitridae as well as Falconidae).
Below are fifteen examples of species names that are now placed some distance taxonomically from their original (or early) genera. Some are still recognised as valid species, some have been synonymised with other species. What I want you to do is tell me what these animals really are:
1. The 'ciliate' Vorticella cinctum.
2. The 'snail' Helix smaragdus.
3. The 'nautilus' Nautilus radicula.
4. The 'harvestman' Phalangium cancroides.
5. The 'crab' Cancer pulex.
6. The 'starfish' Asterias bifida.
7. The 'sea cucumber' Holothuria priapus.
8. The 'stickleback' Gasterosteus volitans.
9. The 'condor' Vultur fulvus.
10. The 'hoopoe' Upupa eremita.
11. The 'anteater' Myrmecophaga striata.
12. The 'lemur' Lemur simiasciurus.
13. The 'mouse' Mus canguru.
14. The 'otter' Lutra minima.
15. The 'civet' Viverra cancrivora.
And as a bonus point:
16. The 'slug' Limax lanceolatus.
Winners win the right to say "I won".
Picture Credits:
Vorticella used before, but original source page appears to have vanished.
Helix pomatia by Janek Pfeiffer.
Nautilus from here.
Phalangium opilio from Morten Hansen.
Cancer productus by Dave Cowles.
Asterias forbesi from here.
Holothuria edulis from here.
Gasterosteus aculeatus from here.
Vultur gryphus from here.
Upupa epops by Claudio Torresani.
Myrmecophaga tridactyla by Christopher Reiger.
Lemur catta from here.
Mus musculus from here.
Lutra lutra by David Pape.
Viverra zibetha by Robert Sterndale.
Limax maximus by Matthew Bulbert.
- Home
- Angry by Choice
- Catalogue of Organisms
- Chinleana
- Doc Madhattan
- Games with Words
- Genomics, Medicine, and Pseudoscience
- History of Geology
- Moss Plants and More
- Pleiotropy
- Plektix
- RRResearch
- Skeptic Wonder
- The Culture of Chemistry
- The Curious Wavefunction
- The Phytophactor
- The View from a Microbiologist
- Variety of Life
Field of Science
-
-
From Valley Forge to the Lab: Parallels between Washington's Maneuvers and Drug Development4 weeks ago in The Curious Wavefunction
-
Political pollsters are pretending they know what's happening. They don't.4 weeks ago in Genomics, Medicine, and Pseudoscience
-
-
Course Corrections5 months ago in Angry by Choice
-
-
The Site is Dead, Long Live the Site2 years ago in Catalogue of Organisms
-
The Site is Dead, Long Live the Site2 years ago in Variety of Life
-
Does mathematics carry human biases?4 years ago in PLEKTIX
-
-
-
-
A New Placodont from the Late Triassic of China5 years ago in Chinleana
-
Posted: July 22, 2018 at 03:03PM6 years ago in Field Notes
-
Bryophyte Herbarium Survey7 years ago in Moss Plants and More
-
Harnessing innate immunity to cure HIV8 years ago in Rule of 6ix
-
WE MOVED!8 years ago in Games with Words
-
-
-
-
post doc job opportunity on ribosome biochemistry!9 years ago in Protein Evolution and Other Musings
-
Growing the kidney: re-blogged from Science Bitez9 years ago in The View from a Microbiologist
-
Blogging Microbes- Communicating Microbiology to Netizens10 years ago in Memoirs of a Defective Brain
-
-
-
The Lure of the Obscure? Guest Post by Frank Stahl12 years ago in Sex, Genes & Evolution
-
-
Lab Rat Moving House13 years ago in Life of a Lab Rat
-
Goodbye FoS, thanks for all the laughs13 years ago in Disease Prone
-
-
Slideshow of NASA's Stardust-NExT Mission Comet Tempel 1 Flyby13 years ago in The Large Picture Blog
-
in The Biology Files
Taxonomy Trivia Quiz #2: You've Come a Long Way, Baby
13 comments:
Markup Key:
- <b>bold</b> = bold
- <i>italic</i> = italic
- <a href="http://www.fieldofscience.com/">FoS</a> = FoS
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I'll try, without looking anything up:
ReplyDelete1. A rotifer?
2. No idea
3. A foraminiferan?
4. No idea, maybe some kind of crustacean? Or a mite?
5. Daphnia pulex (Water flea)?
6. No idea
7. A priapulid
8. Species name suggests this is a flying fish
9. Gyps fulvus (Griffon vulture)
10. Geronticus eremita (Waldrapp/Northern Bald Ibis), known to Linnaeus only from descriptions, as it was already extinct in Europe in his time and not yet rediscovered in northern Africa
11. Numbat?
12. No idea
13. Seems to be a kangaroo from the species name
14. Otter shrew?
15. No idea
16. Branchiostoma lanceolatum (the lancelet)
Lars, I'll give you six of those. Well done.
ReplyDeleteNot cool Christopher -- I'm supposed to be working on my dissertation proposal.
ReplyDeleteAh well, Lars beat me to most of the ones I had an idea for.
to fill in, I'm guessing:
4 = pseudoscorpion? Chelifer cancroides
6 = a feather star?
13 = kangaroo rat? Dipodomys
15 = crab eating raccoon? Procyon cancrivorus
I think I've worked a few more out with the google, but that's cheating so I'll leave them for others
This one seems a lot harder to me. I will guess that Viverra cancrivora is now Procyon cancrivorus?
ReplyDeleteOh, and 12 sounds kind of like a tree shrew.
ReplyDeleteNeil got two, Mike got a round number. I'll put the answers up tomorrow.
ReplyDeleteRounded up or down? Or ... just ... round?...
ReplyDelete1. Peridinium cinctum ?
ReplyDeleteSo this means someone thought it was a good idea to mistake a fucking dino for Vorticella? Or some other kind of taxonomic mess?
So we're basically looking for things with above listed names as basionyms?
and hold on... please don't post answers yet! Have an unrelated exam to study for, so this is a perfect opportunity to procrastinate via...taxonomy...wow.
ReplyDeleteThis is kinda fun, in a very disturbing way...
(we are allowed to look stuff up, right?)
ReplyDelete2. Turbo smaragdus?
3. Nodosaria radicula (foram)
4. Ischyropsalis hadzii?
http://insects.tamu.edu/research/collection/hallan/acari/Family/Ischyropsalididae.txt
5. Gammarus pulex
http://decapoda.nhm.org/pdfs/26050/26050.pdf (bloody scanned docs are unsearchable! Had to
rediscover the 'index' >.<)
6. Antedon bifida (feather star)
http://www.marbef.org/data/aphia.php?p=taxdetails&id=123717
7. Priapulus caudatus (worm)?
http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Priapulus_caudatus
8. Pterois volitans (lionfish)?
http://www.catalogueoflife.org/show_species_details.php?record_id=6211020
9. Gyps fulvus (griffon vulture)
http://www.birdcheck.co.uk/main/previewpages/previewpage131.htm
10. Geronticus eremita (northern bald ibis)
http://taxonomicon.taxonomy.nl/TaxonName.aspx?id=639145&tree=0.1
11. Tamandua? Seriously, I give up...!
http://books.google.ca/books?id=dbU3d7EUCm8C&sitesec=reviews&source=gbs_navlinks_s
12. Eulemur mongoz (Mongoose Lemur)?
http://books.google.ca/books?
id=1s8UAAAAIAAJ&printsec=frontcover&source=gbs_navlinks_s#v=onepage&q=&f=false
13. Jaculus canguru (kangaroo rat)?
http://www.palaeos.org/Macropus
14. Latra minima/Chironectes minimus (water opossum)
http://www.faunaparaguay.com/mammalshb1.pdf p.17
15. Urva cancrivora (crab-eating mongoose)?
(Can't find supporting document - this one is entirely a google-based hunch =P)
Bonus: Branchiostoma lanceolatum (lancelet)
http://www.marinespecies.org/aphia.php?p=taxdetails&id=104906
How many did I get?
I really suck at deciphering taxonomy... >_>
(we are allowed to look stuff up, right?)
ReplyDeleteNo-one else did... (Though that was why I expected this quiz to be easier, because I thought people would probably be able to find most of the answers through Google).
There's still three entries that no-one has successfully identified. Hint: all three are South American. (Indeed, I only noticed after I put it together that this whole quiz has a noticeable South American bias.)
12. It seems you are looking for kinkajou Potos flavus? How anyone thought it was a flipping lemur is quite beyond me.
ReplyDelete11. Myrmecophaga striata - based on a specimen of coati (Nasua nasua), apparently.
ReplyDelete12. Lemur simiasciurus - kinkajou (Potos flavus)
13. Mus canguru - eastern grey kangaroo (Macropus giganteus)
14. Lutra minima - yapok (Chironectes minimus)
15. Viverra cancrivora - crab-eating raccoon (Procyon cancrivorus)